Jayme Jaramillo

 

Article Critique #1

 

Bushweller, Kevin.  American School Board Journal: Technology Focus.  “Gateways to the Internet: A host of companies want to be your district’s customized education portal”. http://asbj.com.2000/11/1100technologyfocus.html Accessed 5/31/03. 

 

         

Computer companies are contacting school systems and trying to entice them to access their Internet Company by promising financial rewards.  Unfortunately, the promises, along with the dot.com world, often falls apart, are leaving school systems with wasted time.  This exact scenario has happened in many districts.  For example, Kickstart.com promised the Denver school system 2.5 cents each time students and/or accessed information through their Internet site, but Kickstart.com ran out of money and could not pay the school system.  An education portal, which some people believe is imperative for safe research by students, is a search engine, which tailors the needs of the users and tries to make Internet research more user friendly.  Education portals are being created constantly and competing to gain the service of school systems; however, it is hard to know which portals are reputable.  The state of Virginia just signed a deal with AOL@SCHOOL, a new education portal.  The companies promise to decipher between useful and useless web sites.  Another new Internet program created by SchholNet is being attempted in South Carolina.  The program creates a one-room electronic schoolhouse, which can be accessed by parents, teachers, students, etc.  The problem is determining whether or not the company is promoting education or economic gain.

The article is very informative and provides concrete examples of how the business world can rob school systems.  Although computers are an imperative part of education, they cannot replace traditional classroom instruction for all students.  Computers and technology should be used to enhance learning, but school systems should be apprehensive before putting too much time into new start-up programs.  Education systems, such as AOL@SCHOOL are probably more trust-worthy than a small dot.com company trying to increase user numbers.  It is a difficult situation, because school systems want to provide students with state of the art equipment and help them succeed.  It is hard to determine whether a new system, which sounds tremendous, is worthwhile or a waste of time.  This is a prime example of the business world and politics playing a role in the world of education.  There are benefits to using education portal systems, because they can monitor student Internet access and only provide reputable sites.  Although computers have been around for quite some time now and are a part of our everyday lives, there is always more to learn and beware of!