BEST & WORST OF SEARCH ENGINES

By Melissa Fleming

 

   There are thousands and thousands of websites to choose from when you want to do a search on the web.  I never realized that there were so many…and in some cases too many!  What I have done is too come up with sites for some of the best and worst sites out there, and for each category the ones that impressed or made me run the other way!  I looked at some of the criteria that was on the Berkley website too help me in my search, and then went searching away…Here is what I came up with.

 

General Search Engines

 And the winner is….Google – I love this website.  If there is a place where you could find a ton of information, then this is the place.  You have different categories to search from, and an advanced search that helps you in narrowing down your choices.  Once you put in your choice, press search, and get your results, you are also able to look through the categories that are on the other pages.  Although it can be tedious to look through all those sites, but you will be pleased that so many results do come up.  Links also seem to be up-to-date.  Date visited – 09/30/03.  http://www.google.com      

 

And 2nd place belongs too…Yahoo – What I love most about Yahoo is the related searches that come up when you hit for you results.  This is another way of narrowing down what you are looking for, in case you are trying to find something specific.  Like Google you come up with an enormous amount of sites, and even though it can be a bit tedious to search through them all, I would rather have too many sites to sort through then none at all.  Also like the more sites about section that follows the link, so you can see other results that are sorted together.  Date visited – 09/30/03.

http://www.yahoo.com/ 

 

Kid Safe Search Engines

 And the winner is….Yahooligans – A much scaled down version of the adult search engine, this is such a fun and informative site….it made me want to be a kid again so I could search the web!  Categories are direct, and this site offers a bunch of fun links where they can play games, or learn some fun facts.  The color and graphic will keep kids interested, and I would feel “safe” letting students navigate through this site with no parental guidance.  The help section is very informative, and will answer the most basic questions.  Date visited – 9/30/03.  http://www.yahooligans.com/ 

 

And 2nd place belongs too…Ask Jeeves Kids – Site is simple, and will not distract your child or student.  If the child knows what question to ask, then this is the place for them to type in that question and get a great answer.  Loved the books on the site that will help them in specific information they are looking for.  The help page needed to be a little more condensed down, since it can go on forever, and for a younger child this might be hard to read, or they may give up….besides that very good site!  Date visited – 09/30/03.  http://www.ajkids.com/

 

Meta Search Engines

 And the winner is….Dogpile – Uses all the latest and greatest general web engines for their searches.  Easy to navigate through and when completing a search will categorize your findings in different subheadings, which helps when you are looking for something specific.  Was a tips and tools link for help in narrowing down your search and even offers a special section for students doing homework, which is an extra added plus for teachers and students.  Able too search in different categories, such as news, audio, images, etc.  Also able too download toolbar for further use.  First time on the site, and I plan on using again for research real soon!  Date visited – 9/30/03.  http://www.dogpile.com/

 

And 2nd place belongs too…Metacrawler – Coming in a very close second, this website offers most everything that dogpile did, except a special section for students doing research, which would have made it just as good as dogpile.  Also categorizes major subjects into subheadings, which makes the “weeding through” of the websites so much easier.  I loved taking a look at the metaspy link which shows you what subjects are being looked up on metacrawler as we spoke….very interesting, yet very scary at the same time!  Another website I have never checked out before today, but will again!  Date visited – 9/30/03.   http://www.metacrawler.com/   

 

News Search Engines

 And the winner is….CNN – This is where I get my major news from.  It is not too jumbled with information, and categories are specific, and when you click on the link you are given the most up to date information that is in relevant.  The Offbeat news section is lite in this serious time.  The partners affiliated with CNN are reputable, and if you need to search for something, then you will be able to search through Google.  CNN is a very trustworthy news source, and this is why I would come here first for my daily news dose.  Date visited – 09/30/03.  http://www.cnn.com/   

 

And 2nd place belongs too…YahooDailyNews – Very informative up to date information for those that want to know that is going on here and now.  Categories on the side make for a wide arrange of topics you can check out the news on.  The top story section on different links is great if you want to look at different sources of information.  Like the resources section, where you able to look up your regional news.  Besides serious news, also give you some fun categories so you can get a laugh.  Nice blend of news information.  Date visited – 09/30/03.   http://dailynews.yahoo.com/      

 

Shopping Search Engines

And the winner is….BizRate – Put a product in and you will find it here.  The comparison pricing is such a help, because you are able to find the product you want at a reasonable price without having to search all over the web on each individual site.  The store coupons and rebates section are what make this web site just better than mySimon.  Also being able to see special offers and store rating are helpful when you are deciding on what store you would like to purchase from.  Date visited - 09/30/03.   http://www.bizrate.com/

 

And 2nd place belongs too…mySimon – Another fun site if you are in the mood for comparison shopping.  I have used this site before, and it is so easy to navigate from one page to another and easy check out.  I like the top products and shopping picks section so you could see what is popular right now.  Have pretty much the same stores as BizRate, so according to what you feel comfortable with, either site would be wonderful for comparison shopping.  Date visited – 09/30/03.  http://www.mysimon.com/

 

Worst Search Engines

 And the winner is….About – Although there is a vast amount of information on the site, it is difficult to search through.  Information is cluttered, and I had trouble navigating from place to place.  Even when searching from other search engines, if I were to even click on a link that lead to this site I would feel overwhelmed.  Some people may love this site, but I click out of it or press the back key immediately.  There is no method too the madness…  Date visited - 09/30/03.   http://www.about.com/  

 

And 2nd place belongs too…Wisenut – Just the opposite of about.com, simple is nice, but this is a little too simple.  There is no advanced search, and the WiseSearch just seems not much of a help.  The sneak peak section just seems pretty useless to me because you are not really getting much information.  There are much better search engines than this, so I would take the time to search through them than to take the time here.  Date visited – 09/30/03.  http://www.wisenut.com/