Course Module:

  WebQuest Evaluation


by:

Lauren Day-Lewis

SLM 521
Fall 2004


Objectives:  Through this assignment students will be able to:
                          
                                                                      

Introduction:  Today, technology plays a major role in the classroom.  The internet offers images, sounds, graphics, and texts which aid in engaging students in the material and enhancing learning.  Therefore, it is important for teachers to use online learning activities in the classroom.  Online instructional activities can increase understanding and comprehension in different subjects.  They also allow students to work in groups and share information with one another.  One great example of an online instructional activity is the WebQuest.  According to Bernie Dodge, a professor who came up with the idea of WebQuests,  WebQuests are “inquiry-oriented activities in which some or all of the information that learners interact with comes from resources on the internet” (Dodge 1995).  On this page you will find more information about WebQuests, links to actual WebQuests and an activity that will help you to determine what makes a good WebQuest!

            
    WebQuests:

Activity:  

1.  Please review the information below concerning WebQuests.  

      
    Components of a WebQuest:
                   
  1. Introduction – two or three sentences that capture the interest of the student.
  2. Task – Specifically state and describe the activity’s end product.
  3. Process – What strategies should students follow to complete the activity.
  4. Resources – Include a list of Websites (links) for students to gather information from.
  5. Evaluation – Measures the results of the activity.
  6. Conclusion – What was the purpose of the activity?  What did the students gain?

2.  Here are three WebQuests that have already been developed and completed by different instructors.  Please click on each             link and spend some time viewing each WebQuest.  

            Personal Reflections on Vietnam - http://oncampus.richmond.edu/academics/education/projects/webquests/vietnam/

Capital Punishment - http://coe.west.asu.edu/students/ahudson/WebQuest.html

Immigrating to America - http://www.macomb.k12.mi.us/wq/webq98/immig.htm




3.  Now, please answer the following questions.

    Do the WebQuests that we just viewed:

  •             Include graphics?
  •             Contain the components you reviewed earlier?
  •             Allow students to explore a particular topic or subject in more depth?
  •             Include activities and/or questions that require the students to evaluate and analyze certain material?

    What do you like best about the WebQuests we just viewed?

    Can you think of any improvements or changes that need to be made to any of these WebQuests?


4.  Next, click on the links below to determine whether or not the WebQuests are "accomplished" or "fully-developed":


http://webquest.sdsu.edu/webquestrubric.html

http://www.spa3.k12.sc.us/webquestrubric.htm


5.  Please answer the following questions:

  •         After reviewing the rubric and evaluation form for WebQuests, do you think that the example WebQuests we viewed earlier need improvement?
  •         If so, what parts would you change (overall visual appeal, process, task)?

Assignment:  

After viewing a few WebQuests, you should be able to recognize a quality or accomplished WebQuest.  Choose one of the WebQuests you viewed or find another WebQuest online and thoroughly evaluate this WebQuest.  Please answer the following questions and use the following criteria in your evaluation to determine whether or not the WebQuest you chose is beginning, developing, or accomplished.  You will need go back and review the WebQuest Rubric links (right above) to see how the each of the criterion are defined.   

In your assignment include the following:

    1.  The name of the WebQuest you choose to evaluate and the name of the person who created the WebQuest.
    2.  Describe the WebQuest (describe the components of this particular WebQuest - what is the topic, task, process?).
    3.  
Why you chose to evaluate this particular WebQuest?
    4.  What you like best (or dislike) about this WebQuest?
    5.  Any additions or suggestions for improvement.
    6.  Your evaluation (based on the criteria you viewed in the WebQuest Rubric links).
                        -  visual appeal
                        -  navigation and flow
                        -  quality of resources
                        -  etc.
    7.  An annotation of the WebQuest you chose (including the link).
                       


Submission:  After you complete the assignment, post your assignment as an html file to the McDaniel web server and create a link to it on your web index page.  Be sure to submit your assignment to your instructor as an attachment in an email or include a hot link and the URL to your site in the email.


Rubric:


Components
Basic (1)
Developing (2)
Accomplished (3)
Title, Creator, and Description of the WebQuest
Only includes the title and person who created the WebQuest
Includes the title, creator, and one or two sentences describing the WebQuest
Includes title, creator, and three or four sentences describing the topic, task, and process of the WebQuest
Your opinions concerning the WebQuest (likes, dislikes, comments, etc.)
Including no personal opinions/comments about the WebQuest:
One sentence containing what you liked about the WebQuest
Stating exactly what you liked best or disliked about the WebQuest and providing a few other comments or suggestions for improvement

Your Evaluation
Only includes some (1-4) of the criteria, and only has a brief and vague description of whether or not the WebQuest matches the criteria
Includes most of the criteria, and only has a brief and vague description of whether or not the WebQuest matches the criteria Includes 6 or more of the criteria for evaluating a WebQuest, and provides a detailed description of whether or not the WebQuest matches this criteria
  

Other Resources:

For Developing WebQuests:

WebQuest Template -
http://www.spa3.k12.sc.us/WebQuestTemplate/webquesttemp.htm

WebQuest Design Map - http://edweb.sdsu.edu/webquest/Process/WebQuestDesignProcess.html

Developing a Webquest - http://www.saskschools.ca/curr_content/techclass/wq/writing.html

Creating a WebQuest Article - http://www.educationworld.com/a_tech/tech/tech011.shtml

Other WebQuests (examples):

Our "Sun"-Sational Star -
http://www.geocities.com/EnchantedForest/Mountain/4240/

A Day in the Life of Harry Potter - http://its.guilford.k12.nc.us/webquests/harry/harry.htm

Life in Rural Louisianna - http://asterix.ednet.lsu.edu/~edtech/webquest/laRural.htm

Investing in Your Future - http://www.esc2.net/TIELevel2/projects/stocks/

Culture Quest - http://coe.west.asu.edu/students/stennille/ST3/webquest.html