How can a plant defend itself given it can not escape by movement? :

Evidence that herbivory defenses are critical for plant survival can be found in the following article....



















 

 

Island plants wimps compared to mainland cousins [ from ENN]

Put a non-native animal on an island and you can expect the native plants to pay a big price, according to a study published this month. Plants unique to Santa Cruz Island, for instance, don't stand a chance against introduced sheep, in part because they have smaller spines and contain fewer noxious compounds than their mainland cousins, say Lizabeth Bowen and Dirk Van Vuren of the University of California at Davis in the October issue of Conservation Biology.

It has long been suspected that island species are more vulnerable to extinction because they lack defenses against introduced predators and herbivores, but the Bowen-Van Vuren study provides the first proof of why.

Learning why island species are vulnerable to extinction is critical for two reasons. First, islands are home to much of the world's biodiversity -- for example, although they account for only 1.4 percent of the land surface, islands support 10 percent of all mammal species. Second, island species die out at a greater rate than mainland species: about three times as many island species have gone extinct since 1600.

"We have provided the first evidence for a major cause -- if not the major cause -- of extinctions worldwide over the past 400 years," says Van Vuren.

To test the theory that island species lack defenses against introduced predators, Bowen and Van Vuren compared six plants that live on Santa Cruz Island (which lies about 20 miles off the coast of southern California) with closely related mainland species. These plants include, Big-pod ceanothus (Ceanothus megacarpus), Island cherry (Prunus ilicifolia), Bush poppy (Dendromecon rigida), Mountain mahogany (Cercocarpus betuloides), Christmas berry (Heteromeles arbutifolia), and Scrub oak (Quercus dumosa). The researchers found that in general the island plants had fewer morphological defenses (spines were as much as 80 percent shorter and leaves were up to four times larger) as well as fewer chemical defenses (tannin levels were as much as 57 percent lower and phenol levels were as much as 73 percent lower).

The researchers also showed that these under-defended island plants were far more palatable to non-native herbivores: when offered both mainland and island plants of the same species, hungry sheep ate as much as 2.5 times more of the latter.

By wiping out island plants, introduced herbivores can also threaten the island animals that depend on them. For example, the palila, a bird unique to the Big Island of Hawaii, is endangered because sheep destroyed its forest habitat. Similarly, a snake unique to Round Island, which is in the Indian Ocean, has apparently gone extinct because populations of the lizards it ate plummeted after introduced rabbits and goats destroyed their palm savanna habitat.

For more information, contact Dirk Van Vuren, UC Davis, (916)752-4181,.....email: dhvanvuren@ucdavis.edu.



But exactly how can a plant defend itself against both small and large herbivores. At the most basic level we can start with external features that help repel these eaters....
1. Morphological adaptations:

  • Control of microclimate by modifying either leaf temperature or humidity
    Insects are very sensitive to humidity- can't tolerate dry/wet fluctuations

  • Make it difficult to maneuver on the leaf
    Make it very smooth ( holly) or very rough with trichomes- these are hairs on the leaf often with barbs that may even in some cases contain irritants or poisons. ie. subtle as squash inducing a rash


    • Gummosis-sticky stuff that jams up a probisus and sclerids- internal sharp projections which can wear down chewing molars... as in pears

      In C4 grasses, bundle sheaths around the central vein of xylem and phloem, may include a silica ( glass-like) layer which requires grinding by the the herbivore to consume...

    • 2. Nutritional keep moisture below 60% especially potent with fungi who need moisture - or keep N / amino acid levels low which makes it difficult for insects or larger animals to survive on a high carbohydrate & low protein diet. Consider adaptation made by large herbivores to compensate for their low digestable, high carbohydrate diet of grasses...


Biochemical defenses: secondary metabolites:
as you can see from the diagram below, these are compounds produced in the process of the synthesis of other necessary metabolites... somewhere along the line the production of these compounds allowed the plant to survive better, and subsequent modifications were selected for.



Evolution of these molecules has occurred over a long period of time....Over 30,000+ compounds are known to be produced by plants; actual # unknown

  • Some of these alter the hormonal cycle of insects leading to altered life cycles, others act to denature proteins, others alter DNA/CH structure by attaching to them, and so on. In bracken ferns these compounds are strong enough a deterant to repulse most potential herbivores.


  • One chemical family of secondary metabolites includes the:

    Alkaloids: contain a N-containing heterocycle

  • Derived from aa's : ornithine, lysine, phenylalanine etc
  • 3000+ known

    Examples: Nicotine, caffeine, morphine, colchcine, ergots, LSD, strychnine, quinine, resperine

     

  • Known effects of alkaloids on mammals:
    1. Inhibit /activate enzymes - ADH (alcohol dehydrogenase), phosphatases
    Inhibit phosphodiesters which normally destroy cAMP which is involved in breakdown of fats and carbohydrates. Net result - it alters storage of carbohydrates & fats

    2. Effects nucleic acid & protein synthesis
  • certain alkaloids bind to nucleic acids, intercalates with DNA --->; makes DNA susceptible to UV damage, effects binding of regulators, effects repair
  • binds with RNA: affects transcription, r-RNA formation, can cause chain terminations

    3. Affects membrane structure and cytoskeletal structure- cellular weakening or collapse
    4. Can affect nerve transmission / induction - 'that first cup of coffee in the morning effect.'...

    5. It may alter energy dynamics- use of energy from detoxification
    with MFO (NADPH-dependent) / conjugation systems reduces energy for growth and can also alter acid balance with release of glucuronic acid used in conjugation

    Specific examples of alkaloids include:

  • Steroid alkaloids ie. Zygacine from the Death Camus plant induces vomiting, diarrhea, decreased heart rate, gastroenteritis, subnormal temperature- (simulated death state) - use din vodoo practices
  • Indole ring ie. Vincristine: reduced white blood count used in leukemia from the Periwinkle plant


  • B. Given that in spite of defenses it still occurs, how does herbivory affect plants when it occurs......?
    (this includes sap sucking, flower &fruit consumption,root pruning)

    1. Generally non-lethal unless pre-stressed or just making it
    parts not whole plant usually consumed

    2. A lot depends on the response of the plant:
    Compensation by the plant by:
  • herbivory can just help reduce self-shading
  • plant may respond by mobilization of stored carbohydrates or nutrients gnerally from the roots
  • plant may attempt to regain Shoot/root ratio
  • plant may increase rate of photosynthesis
  • plant meristems may produce new tissue to replace lost


    Sometimes however the plant may
    not be able to compensate if:

  • ring barking/ girdling or eat off all meristematic buds as with hungry deer or swarms of insects
  • introduce a disease in the process of herbivory

    **Note: If 2 species are competing, the introduction of a predator may caue one or the other to win out or allow both to survive